I started listening to this siren song some time ago and began to all but remove grammar from my lesson plans. I gave some feedback, but gone was the 90 minute lesson on getting all our 'if's and 'would's in the right place. But over time, I feel the pull of grammar bringing me back and while I'm still not running entire lessons focused on a certain element, grammar is tangible in nearly every lesson. So, I thought I would spell out a few reasons why it's still okay to teach grammar (even to higher levels) and why we can even learn to love it again.
1. Grammar is image
We have been watching Cars a lot in my house lately. Cars and Cars 2 are films from Disney/Pixar about a race car, Lightning McQueen, and his best friend, Tow Mater, a lovable redneck tow truck. In the second movie they introduce Finn McMissile, a soave British secret agent.
|Michael Caine and Larry the Cable Guy. |
Photo of Michael Caine: Harry Wad, both from wikipedia.org
Here's a quiz based on these two pictures:
- Which man is the voice of the lovable redneck tow truck?
- Which man is the voice of the soave British secret agent?
- Who uses the sentence... "My apologies, I haven't properly introduced myself."
- Who uses the sentence, "Ah! I knowed you wasn't gonna leave without sayin' goodbye!"
- Which image would your learners most like to portray?
2. Without grammar it's not language teaching
The basic truth is that our learners expect teaching in grammar. It is one of the core aspects they expect in our classes. Sure they may not want to spend a lot of time listening to the teacher drone on about when to use the past perfect, but grammar is one of the ways they measure their own progress. Unlike vocabulary, which they may or may not see again in their daily lives, they will recognize grammar. It also helps the learners battle ambiguity. Especially in writing, they have fewer doubts, "Is this right or not?" That is a big confidence boost.
3. Grammar is relatively easy to teach
Let's be honest, we can't walk into every classroom every week and be 100% engaged. Setting up and evaluating skills training can be hard work. Listening for lexical gaps and absent functional phrases takes immense concentration. Sometimes we are tired, distracted, or just plain having a rough day. Identifying and filling grammar deficiencies is much easier to do. We should certainly try to do more when monitoring, but it's not always possible.
Grammar provides a great way for the teacher to relax a little bit. We all have a bank of grammar based activities and ideas to draw upon at a moment's notice. We all have our standard way of teaching the present perfect continuous and passive modals. Sometimes it does us good to dust those off and have a nice standard grammar lesson. The learners will get something and the teacher can live to fight another day.
4. Grammar teaching supports awareness of language
By dissecting the language, the learners are practicing the skill of analyzing what they say and how they say it. This supports our other training areas. It shows them that small things can make a huge difference. It then becomes easier to show them how word choice can change the tone of a sentence. We can then show them why formal language is different than informal language. It better enables us to show how discourse markers help the listener to understand. Etc., etc.
I continue to listen politely to my colleagues about grammar. And I will give them one concession, we need to prioritize which grammatical elements to include. There are many steps between Finn McMissile and Tow Mater. We need to think about which elements will help them fit the image they want to portray.
I now include a grammar element in nearly every lesson I have. Sometimes it is planned based on the text/listening, sometimes it is feedback driven, but it is always there. It worries me when dismissing grammar in Business English training becomes so common that we take it for granted. In meetings with other trainers it seems as though we compete at who teaches it the least. This is not the right approach and is not helping our learners. But I suspect many of them are secretly teaching it anyway :)
So, learn to embrace it and love it... just don't let it get too passionate.